I am trying to understand the relationship between positive/negative memories and the congruence of memory to existing beliefs. These quotes are from Wikipedia, presented in alphabetical order:

  • Choice-supportive bias: "positive aspects tend to be remembered as part of the chosen option, whether or not they originally were part of that option, and negative aspects tend to be remembered as part of rejected options."
  • Egocentric bias: "This bias suggests that people remember the past as they want it to be rather than the way it was"
  • Fading affect bias: "a psychological phenomenon in which information regarding negative emotions tends to be forgotten more quickly than that associated with pleasant emotions."
  • Mood congruent memory bias: "the improved recall of information congruent with one's current mood."
  • Mnemic neglect: "a pattern of selective forgetting in which certain autobiographical memories tend to be recalled more easily if they are consistent with positive self-concept."
  • Negativity bias: "the psychological phenomenon by which humans have a greater recall of unpleasant memories compared with positive memories."
  • Placement bias: "tendency to remember ourselves to be better than others at tasks at which we rate ourselves above average and tendency to remember ourselves to be worse than others at tasks at which we rate ourselves below average."
  • Pollyanna principle: "the tendency for people to remember pleasant items more accurately than unpleasant ones."
  • Positivity effect: "older adults' memories are more likely to consist of positive than negative information and more likely to be distorted in a positive direction."
  • Rosy retrospection: "refers to the finding that subjects later rate past events more positively than they had actually rated them when the event occurred"
  • Self-verification: "self-views bias memory recall to favor self-confirming material over non-confirming elements."

Most of these suggest congruence with existing beliefs rather than a strict positive bias, but since "on the balance, most people tend to view themselves positively," it makes sense that there would be a positivity bias overall.

The oddball in the above list is Negativity bias, that appears to contradict other findings. Another exception is Mnemic neglect: "mnemic neglect is based on self-protection rather than self-verification" - ie, there is a strict positive bias, rather than a congruence with existing beliefs, in direct contradiction with research in Self-verification and others.

I think the resolution of these apparent contradictions is in the details: Is the memory about personal experience or just memorizing items? Is the memory self-referent or otherwise? Is the bias referring to memory encoding or memory recall? Is it an issue of missing or distorted memories?

So my question is, is anyone aware of any studies that look at the circumstances under which memory bias is strictly positive, congruent with existing beliefs, strictly negative, or unaffected by mood or belief? Or failing that, a comprehensive review of memory bias that might clarify this?

  • $\begingroup$ Interesting question. I hope to find some to answer it later. $\endgroup$ – Christian Hummeluhr Mar 20 '15 at 10:59

The short answer is: it depends on age. For younger adults, negative memories last longer than positive memories, it's reversed for older adults.

This paper is a good review of some of the above effects: Choice-supportive bias, Mood congruent memory bias, Positivity effect, Negativity bias. For the negative bias, it suggests that it's only true for younger adults, for older adults, negative memories actually lasts for a shorter time than positive memories. Many reasons have been discussed, one of those I like is because of the auto-activation of the emotional regulation ability in older adults (above 60 years old), thus cognitive control is in effect when recalling memories.

Mather, M. (2006). Why memories may become more positive as people age. Memory and emotion: Interdisciplinary perspectives, 135-158.

  • $\begingroup$ Fantastic @Sophy, that is a great find. The paper mentions Socioemotional Selectivity Theory (SST), that supports age-related changes - thank you for the reference! $\endgroup$ – Arnon Weinberg Sep 4 '16 at 2:06

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.