5
$\begingroup$

Irwin D. Yalom is a famous existential psychotherapist who's sporting his own theory about human psychology. Based on psychdynamics, he's stating that questions and thoughts pertaining to death, freedom, meaninglessness, and existential isolation lead to anxiety. Further, when it comes to psychopathology, he states (page 110 of his book Existential psychotherapy) that his theory

as do most paradigms of psychopathology, on the assumption that psychopathology is a graceless, inefficient mode of coping with anxiety.

Now, I'm trying to figure out whether he views all kind of psychopathology this way, and indeed what he thinks counts as psychopathology in the first place. I recon he's not talking about things like for example autism or psychopathy (even though I haven't found any passages where he explicitly excludes these), but what about diagnoses such as schizophrenia?

For Yalom, where does one draw the line between mental illness caused by inefficient coping strategies for anxiety, and brain disorders that simply are due to other reasons?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Are you sure you mean 'are caused by' rather than 'cause or are caused by'? $\endgroup$ – BCLC Aug 11 '15 at 10:19
3
+200
$\begingroup$

The scope of Yalom's mainstream branch is pretty much the same as that of existential psychotherapy, and psychodynamic therapy in general. According to Yalom (p. 9-10):

The dynamic existential approach retains the basic dynamic structure outlined by Freud, but radically alters the content. The old formula of DRIVE -> ANXIETY -> DEFENSE MECHANISM is replaced by AWARENESS OF ULTIMATE CONCERN -> ANXIETY -> DEFENSE MECHANISM. Both formulas assume that anxiety is the fuel of psychopathology;

Psychoanalysis is focused on psychological symptoms, such as neurosis:

There are many different neuroses: obsessive–compulsive disorder, obsessive–compulsive personality disorder, impulse control disorder, anxiety disorder, hysteria, and a great variety of phobias. ... anxiety, sadness or depression, anger, irritability, mental confusion, low sense of self-worth, etc., behavioral symptoms such as phobic avoidance, vigilance, impulsive and compulsive acts, lethargy, etc., cognitive problems such as unpleasant or disturbing thoughts, repetition of thoughts and obsession, habitual fantasizing, negativity and cynicism, etc. Interpersonally, neurosis involves dependency, aggressiveness, perfectionism, schizoid isolation, socio-culturally inappropriate behaviors, etc.

and psychosis, but exclusive of known biological causes:

Medical and biological laboratory tests should exclude central nervous system diseases and injuries, diseases and injuries of other organs, psychoactive substances, toxins, and prescribed medications as causes of symptoms of psychosis before any psychiatric illness can be diagnosed.

As per Yalom (p. 12):

*In this discussion, as elsewhere in this text, I refer to psychologically based disturbance, not to the major psychoses with a fundamental biochemical origin.

This is similar in scope to all forms of psychotherapy, except that where the underlying cause is not known to be physiological or medical in nature, it is assumed to be subconscious (rather than say, behavioural, cognitive, or functional). For psychodynamics:

Psychodynamic therapies depend upon a theory of inner conflict, wherein repressed behaviours and emotions surface into the patient’s consciousness; generally, one's conflict is subconscious.

and specifically, for existential psychotherapy (in Yalom's words p. 8):

... a conflict that flows from the individual's confrontation with the givens of existence.

This also means that the scope of therapy may change over time, as knowledge is gained regarding the root causes of mental disorders.

Pretty much all other mental disorders are fair game, including mood disorders such as anxiety, personality disorders such as psychopathy (ASPD), and thought disorders such as schizophrenia. For example, in chapter 4 (p. 147) of his book - under the "Death" concern - Yalom discusses schizophrenia patients who:

clings to his or her denial of death with a fierce desperation

Note: In cases where some biological factor is assumed, it is common practice to treat disorders with both medication and psychotherapy, as the overall efficacy is improved. In such cases, psychotherapy focuses on the psychological components of the disorder. Even in cases where the role of psychology may seem secondary, such as dementia, learning disability, and autism, psychotherapy may be used to augment treatment. However, psychodynamic therapy is not popular for such disorders, because of the reliance on talk-therapy, that is highly constrained in these cases, so they are unlikely to be discussed much in existential therapy circles.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.